US Pushes New Zealand to Monitor Migration Risks – Will It Change Immigration Policy?

The United States government has raised concerns over migration in New Zealand, urging the US Embassy in Wellington to begin collecting data on migration-related crimes and human rights abuses. This move is part of a broader focus by the Trump administration, which has made migration a key issue both domestically and abroad.

In a recent statement, the US State Department explained that it had directed its embassies across Europe, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand to engage with local governments and highlight the potential risks they associate with migration. The department noted that while New Zealand’s current situation may not be as pressing, the country could face growing challenges in the future if it adopts more open migration policies.

"Our concern isn't necessarily about live migration now, but about the long-term risks of adopting a globalized migration narrative," said a senior US State Department official in a background call. The official emphasized that the US fears the importation of large groups from cultures that may not integrate smoothly, a sentiment reflected in President Trump’s recent remarks about Europe’s struggles with migration.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon was quick to dismiss these concerns, affirming that New Zealand’s immigration policy is a national matter. "Our immigration policy is linked to our economic strategy, and we are very proud of the immigrants who contribute to our society," Luxon stated, highlighting the positive impact of immigration on New Zealand’s growth.

Academic Paul Spoonley, a sociology professor at Massey University, strongly disagreed with the US stance. Spoonley described the US request as “extraordinary” and criticized the move as aligning New Zealand with a political agenda that demonizes immigrants. He pointed out that New Zealand’s immigration history is built on welcoming newcomers who can contribute to the economy and society, especially through the Skilled Migrant Category.

Spoonley also highlighted the political dynamics behind such calls, noting the rise of anti-immigrant rhetoric globally, which he believes distorts the reality of migration. "New Zealand should not be part of this narrative," he said, emphasizing that the country’s approach to immigration has been shaped by practical and inclusive policies.

Recent immigration trends in New Zealand show a decline in migrant arrivals, with StatsNZ reporting a 16% drop in the year ending August 2025. Despite this, the country's immigration system remains selective, aiming to attract individuals who can integrate socially and economically